Donate
Independent, objective, nonpartisan research
Blog Post · September 16, 2021

Unhealthy Air May Threaten Educational Outcomes

photo - Smoke Clouds from Wildfire in Mountain View, California

In recent years, air pollution from California wildfires has been over 120 times greater than pollution from traffic. Exposure to the fine particles in this type of pollution exacerbates conditions like childhood asthma, a chronic disease that disproportionately affects low-income children and contributes to student absenteeism. Today, up to half of fine particulate pollution in the western US may be due to wildfire smoke.

Exposure to air pollution is already a concern for children’s health, and a sizable link may exist between academic achievement and air quality. Therefore, it is crucial to consider how air quality contributes to socioeconomic disadvantage, given that unhealthy air varies across regions and that lower-income communities and communities of color are exposed to it more often.

Forty percent of California’s unhealthy air quality days in the past two decades happened in the last five years. The same period also included about 80% of very unhealthy or hazardous air quality days.

figure - Unhealthy air quality days in California have spiked since 2016

In recent years, the highest-poverty school districts experienced slightly worse air quality, at roughly 15% higher concentrations of unhealthy particles than in the lowest-poverty school districts. However, the average concentration obscures large but infrequent spikes in air pollution. Looking instead at the number of unhealthy days districts experience, we find that both high- and low-poverty districts’ experiences are similar: seven to eight unhealthy days on average per year. In other words, while children in higher-poverty schools are more exposed to unhealthy particles, unhealthy air affects children of all poverty levels. In 2020, a family of four with two children was in poverty if they had incomes less than about $26,300. The figure below splits districts into quartiles based on how many families have incomes at or below this level.

figure - Unhealthy air quality affects school districts of all levels of child poverty

The documented link between academic achievement and air quality could signal new academic challenges for schools in the Central Valley and the Bay Area, the regions most affected by more frequent and severe unhealthy air quality. Unhealthy air quality days were most frequent in the San Joaquin Valley, but the Bay Area had the most striking increases—33 unhealthy days per year on average since 2016, compared to only 6 per year from 2000 to 2015.

figure - Unhealthy air quality days increased in Central and Northern California

Studies of California and national school facilities suggest that many fail to meet indoor air quality standards. If air quality continues to worsen, students at school districts already prone to poor air may face more health and educational challenges. Recent studies have linked poor air quality to lower test scores, absenteeism, and increased suspensions. The average elementary school district experienced about five more unhealthy air quality days in 2016 to 2020 than during the previous 15 years.

Furthermore, if California’s wildfire seasons continue to intensify, policymakers will need to take measures to protect indoor air quality and mitigate health effects for children from exposure to unhealthy air. Failure to do so could have long-term implications on the health and academic success of the next generation of Californians.

Topics

air quality Forests and Fires health Health & Safety Net K–12 Education Poverty & Inequality racial disparities Water, Land & Air wildfires